51 White Elephant Gift Ideas That Actually Get Stolen (2026)

The first white elephant I remember was a business school holiday party in Boston, where someone brought a live lobster in a box. A real, live lobster. I was so glad we didn’t have to take that one home (apparently it’s a tradition). I’ve been to a lot of gift exchanges since, and nobody has topped it.
That party was a gag gift exchange and the lobster was perfect for it. There was also this horrendous wolf sweatshirt. Most of the white elephants I go to now are not that same thing and people are expecting gifts they’re excited about. I’ve sorted these white elephant gift ideas by the kind of party you’re going to. I’ve marked the ones I’ve watched get stolen or be crowd favorites. I host a favorite things or white elephant exchange for my birthday every November, we host kids’ gift exchanges at our house in December, and for years we threw a couples’ holiday party with a themed white elephant. At those parties, the gifts that get fought over are real gifts (not gag gifts). This post contains affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission at no cost to you.
So the real question isn’t what’s funny. It’s this: what kind of white elephant is it, and what would people in that room actually fight over?
Nothing feels better than bringing the gift to the white elephant that gets stolen.
The short answer: for a girls’ night or favorite things party, bring a full bottle of ⭐ Dime perfume (about $50 on sale). I’ve brought two different scents, and both got stolen multiple times. On a $20 limit, Poetry for Neanderthals ($19.99) is the game that gets opened and played before the party’s over. If you want the gift everyone fights over, go a little over the limit with the Sunbeam heated throw ($46.97) or something else they’ve heard of.
Jump to: What kind of party · Quick picks by budget · Girls’ night · Couples · Family · Kids’ exchange · Office · Funny gifts · Rules · What flops · FAQ
First, What Kind of White Elephant Is It?
Before you buy anything, find out which of these you’re walking into, because the same gift can win one party and flop at another.
A gag gift exchange is about the laugh when it’s opened. Think the lobster, or a pickle that tells your fortune. A good-gift exchange is about the thing people want to take home, and that’s most girls’ nights, favorite things parties and family swaps now. A themed exchange sets a category, like the date night edition we did at our couples’ party, where every gift had to be something for a night out (or in) together. Kids’ exchanges are their own thing, and so is the office swap, where you need something nobody could possibly be offended by.
If the invite doesn’t say, ask the host. It’s a much less awkward question than showing up with a Squatty Potty to a party where everyone else brought cashmere socks.
How to Pick a White Elephant Gift Everyone Will Fight Over
After years of these parties, I’ve noticed the gifts that get stolen almost always follow one of three rules.
Rule 1: Bring a name people know but haven’t bought for themselves. Everyone has seen it on social media or smelled it on a friend, and nobody has spent the money yet. That’s why viral perfume and a rhode lip and cheek set go so fast.
Rule 2: Bring more value than the limit. Holiday gift sets, a Black Friday sale or a connection all get you there. At a $50 favorite things party I go to every year, someone who works at lululemon brought a $100 hoodie, and you can imagine how that went. I usually bring an IPSY bag: five products I paid about $35 for that are worth over $120 (don’t worry, I throw in a sixth product or a pair of earrings so I’m at the $50 spend, too).
Rule 3: Or just go over budget. If you want to bring the gift that gets stolen, spending $10 more than everyone else will do it. (Don’t tell the host I said that.)
How I Chose These White Elephant Gift Ideas
Seventeen of these 50+ gifts come from my own life. Some are things we own and use, like the massage candle I light in the bath and the kids’ microscope. Some are gifts I’ve brought that got stolen, and some are gifts I watched get stolen at parties I hosted or went to. The other 34 are picks I haven’t owned. They made the list because they kept showing up on this year’s best-selling and most-wanted lists, on editor gift guides, and in the stories other friends tell about what got fought over at their exchanges. They’d all be fantastic options. Prices and ratings were checked on November 16, 2026.
Quick Picks: The Best White Elephant Gifts by Budget
| Budget | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| ⭐ Favorite overall | Dime perfume (about $50) | Brought two scents, both stolen |
| Under $15 | Taco Cat Goat Cheese Pizza ($9.97) | The slap game that gets played at the party |
| Under $15 | 3D nail art pens ($9.99) | Stolen at our kids’ exchange last year and still used at our house |
| Under $15 | Melting Snowball Mystery Cash bath bomb ($12) | Real cash hidden inside |
| $15 to $25 | Poetry for Neanderthals ($19.99) | Our family’s funniest game |
| $15 to $25 | Laneige Midnight Minis ($23) | Five lip masks in one holiday set |
| $15 to $25 | Emotional support crochet animals ($25.99) | The gag gift people keep on their desk |
| $25 to $50 | rhode Pocket Pair ($38) | Sold out online when I checked |
| $25 to $50 | Chuao More Joy chocolate set ($29.99) | 16 mini bars to trade and taste |
| $25 to $50 | MELONY massage candle ($30.99) | The one I light in the bath |
| Over the limit, on purpose | Sunbeam heated throw ($46.97) | The family-swap gift people fight over |
| Over the limit, on purpose | Quince Balsam Fir candle ($50) | Mine gets compliments every time (if the $100 one goes on sale, grab it) |
| Over the limit, on purpose | Restaurant gift card plus a reservation | Always stolen at our couples’ party |
White Elephant Gift Ideas for a Girls’ Night or Favorite Things Party
These are for the good-gift parties: the girls’ night swap, the favorite things party, the mom group exchange. Every one passes at least one of my three rules.

⭐ Dime Perfume, 7 Summers or Dans Les Bois (about $50)
Best for: a $50 girls’ night or favorite things party
Dime’s perfumes are clean, everyday scents in a pretty bottle, and they’re the gift I’ve had stolen the most. I’ve brought 7 Summers and Dans Les Bois to favorite things parties, and both got stolen. I paid about $48 a bottle back then. They’re $62 now, but Dime runs sales often and creator codes take 20 to 30% off, which puts a full bottle right around a $50 limit. My Dime perfume review has every scent I’ve tried.
What to know: For a $25 party, the sample kit is $28 and lets the winner try the whole line before she picks a favorite.

Five IPSY Products in an IPSY Bag (about $30)
Best for: a $25 or $30 party where you want to bring the most value
This is my favorite trick for a gift that gets stolen. I keep a stash of unopened products from my IPSY boxes, and before a party I pick five and tuck them into one of the cute IPSY makeup bags. It’s about $30 of my money and usually worth more than $120 at full price, and unwrapping five things is more fun than unwrapping one. I wrote a full IPSY review if you want to start a subscription for exactly this reason.
What to know: Pick products anyone can use (a lip product, skincare, a hair mask) and skip anything shade-matched like foundation.

Quince Balsam Fir 3-Wick Candle ($50)
Best for: anyone, right before the holidays
A big candle with a really good pine scent is the right gift right before the holidays. I have the huge Balsam Fir luxury candle ($100), and I have never gotten so many compliments on how my house smells. This 3-wick is the same scent at half the price, with 4.9 stars from 631 reviews.
What to know: Quince runs holiday sales, so check it the week before your party. The Capri Blue Volcano candle from Anthropologie is another huge hit at most parties I go to.

rhode Pocket Pair, Pocket Blush and Peptide Lip Tint ($38)
Best for: the newest, most-wanted beauty gift at a $40 or $50 party
rhode is the beauty brand everyone has seen on social media this year, and the limited-edition Pocket Pair holiday set is a Pocket Blush and a Peptide Lip Tint together for $38 (listed as a $45 value). When I checked on November 16, all three color pairs were sold out online at Sephora, which is exactly why it would get stolen. If it’s still sold out, buy the same two pieces separately: Pocket Blush in sprinkle ($25) and Peptide Lip Tint in ribbon ($20). That pink pair is the easiest one to give someone you don’t know well.
What to know: For a $25 party, the new Pocket Bronze is $25 on its own. It launched in June with the biggest waitlist in rhode’s history.

Laneige Midnight Minis Lip Sleeping Mask Set ($23)
Best for: a $20 to $25 party
Laneige’s Lip Sleeping Mask is one of the most consistent beauty best sellers under $25, and this limited-edition holiday set has five minis in Berry, Vanilla, Lemon Sorbet, Mango and Watermelon Pop, plus a few skincare samples. Five flavors to try makes it feel bigger than $23. The full-size lip mask has more than 22,000 reviews at Sephora.
What to know: Holiday sets sell out, so grab it early if your party is mid-December.

Sephora Favorites Perfume Discovery Set with a Scent Certificate ($38)
Best for: a perfume gift when you don’t know her scent
This is perfume minus the guessing. The set has mini sprays of popular perfumes plus a certificate she trades in at Sephora for a travel-size spray of the one she likes best. It’s $38 for a listed $56 value, and it fits my perfume rule without a blind-buy scent.
What to know: It’s final sale, and the certificate gets her a travel size, not a full bottle.

OUAI Get On Your Merry OUAI Kit ($39)
Best for: a fancy shampoo gift that smells amazing
Fancy shampoo always gets stolen at girls’ nights, because everyone uses it and nobody wants to pay for the good stuff. A few years ago I brought an R+Co set and it was a big hit, and I’ve also been given Dae. This year I’d bring OUAI, the brand people buy for its scent. The holiday kit has the Detox Shampoo, Super Dry Shampoo and the North Bondi Leave In Conditioner for $39 (listed as a $48 value), with 4.4 stars from 90 reviews at Ulta, the only place that sells it.
What to know: It’s a leave-in, not a rinse-out conditioner. For a $50 party, OUAI’s St Barts kit at Ulta is $45 (a $58 value).

Quince Mini U Huggie Hoops ($38)
Best for: jewelry for someone you don’t know well
Earrings have been a great gift for me at girls’ parties, and small gold huggies are the safest shape for someone whose style you’re guessing at. These are 18K gold vermeil with 4.8 stars from 1,181 reviews. My best jewelry for gifting guide has more under $50.
What to know: Vermeil is gold over sterling silver, so it holds up better than plated jewelry.

Kitsch x The Grinch Hair Perfume Duo ($28.60)
Best for: a $25 to $30 party and anyone who loves a scent
Hair perfume took off on TikTok last fall, and Kitsch is the affordable way to try it. This holiday duo comes in a Grinch box with two mists, Whoville Cookies (warm and sweet) and Cherry Cheer (fruity), and it’s rated 4.8 stars from 247 reviews on Kitsch’s site. It’s a fun unwrap at a Christmas party.
What to know: Kitsch’s Satin Pillowcase in Holiday ($20) makes a cute add-on if your limit is higher.

Chuao Chocolatier More Joy Gift Set ($29.99)
Best for: a chocolate taste test everyone can share
Fancy chocolate is a good-gift classic, and a taste-test box is even better because the winner ends up passing it around. This set from Chuao, a San Diego chocolatier, has 16 mini bars in eight flavors, like potato chip, churro, honeycomb, mango with chile and lime, and one with popping candy that crackles in your mouth. It has 4.95 stars from 20 reviews on Chuao’s site.
What to know: For a cheaper version, Trader Joe’s Taste Test of Caramels is a box of 12 hand-decorated chocolate caramels in different flavors. It’s only sold in stores, so there’s no link.

Kodak Charmera Keychain Camera ($34.99)
Best for: the friend who documents everything
The Charmera is a tiny digital camera on a keychain, sold as a blind box so you don’t know which color you’ll get. The photos are lo-fi on purpose, which is the whole charm, and it sold out for months after it went viral. It’s also in my gifts for women who have everything guide.
What to know: It comes as a blind box, so you can’t pick the color.

Fujifilm QuickSnap Disposable Camera ($19.49)
Best for: a $20 party
A disposable camera is one of my favorite white elephant gifts, because it usually gets passed around and used for the rest of the party. The QuickSnap has a built-in flash, and it has 4.6 stars from 502 reviews at Walmart.
What to know: Developing costs extra, so a few dollars for the photo lab is a nice add.

A Gift Card to Your Own Nail Person ($25 to $50)
Best for: the gift that gets stolen first
At the favorite things party I go to every year, the nail salon gift card is always one of the first gifts stolen. My twist is to give a card to your own nail person. You’re passing along a recommendation you trust, and she gets a new client out of it.
What to know: Write her name and the salon’s number on the card so the winner can book.

A Store Gift Card, Plus One Small Thing From That Store (any amount)
Best for: any limit, any party
A gift card alone is a little flat to unwrap. My favorite version is a pair of Anthropologie socks wrapped up with an Anthropologie gift card. The socks make it fun to open, and the card lets the winner pick something she actually wants.
What to know: Pick a store most people in the room would shop at, not your personal favorite.

Couples’ White Elephant Ideas (the Date Night Edition)
For years we hosted a couples’ holiday party with a white elephant, usually a date night edition with a $50 limit. Every gift had to be something two people could enjoy together.


A Restaurant Gift Card, With a Reservation Tucked In ($50)
Best for: a $50 couples’ party
A gift card to a restaurant everyone loves is my favorite couples’ gift, and in our couples groups a Din Tai Fung gift card always gets stolen. If you can, make a reservation and tuck the confirmation in with the card, so it’s an actual date night instead of a card that sits in a wallet. My favorite places to eat in Orange County has more ideas if you’re local.
What to know: Book a reservation that’s free to cancel, since the winners will probably need to move it.

MELONY Massage Candle, Coconut Cream ($30.99)
Best for: a couple, or anyone who loves a bath
A massage candle is a candle made of shea butter, sweet almond oil and vitamin E that melts into a warm oil. You burn it for about 30 minutes, blow it out, test a drop on your wrist, and pour the oil into your hand. I use mine on my own: I light it in the bath and then use the oil on my arms and shoulders. It works for a couples’ party or a girls’ night, and it has 4.7 stars from 106 reviews.
What to know: It contains almond oil, so skip it for anyone with a nut allergy.

A Movie Night Bundle: Popcorn Maker and Fancy Seasoning (about $35 to $40)
Best for: a themed date night swap
Bundles always get fought over, and a movie night box is the stay-home version of date night. The Dash Fresh Pop is a little hot air popcorn maker that pops up to 16 cups with no oil, and it has 4.6 stars from more than 2,300 reviews at Walmart. Diaspora Co.’s popcorn seasoning makes it taste like you went out. Add a box of candy and a movie rental card if your limit has room.
What to know: Air-popped popcorn is dry, so tuck in a jar of kernels and tell them to melt a little butter first so the seasoning sticks.

Nostalgia Indoor Electric S’mores Maker ($32.99)
Best for: a couples’ or family party
This is a flameless s’mores maker for the table, with a little electric heater in the middle and trays for the graham crackers, chocolate and marshmallows around it. It’s a date night at home, and it’s a hit with kids too. It has 4.5 stars at Walmart.
What to know: It doesn’t come with the food, so tape a bag of marshmallows to the box.

An Experience for Two (varies)
Best for: a couples’ party with a bigger limit
Experience gifts were a regular at our date night edition. A pottery or cooking class, Topgolf or a comedy show all work, and I took a Sur La Table cooking class and loved it. Airbnb Experiences is a great place to find something local, and an Airbnb gift card in the box lets the winners book the one they want.
What to know: Pick an experience that’s easy to schedule, or give the gift card so they can choose.

Sky Team ($32.99)
Best for: couples who like a game night for two
Sky Team is a two-player cooperative game where you’re the pilot and co-pilot trying to land a plane together, and it’s the first two-player game ever to win the Spiel des Jahres, the big board game award, in 2024. Because you win or lose together, nobody is sore on the drive home. It has 4.7 stars from more than 1,100 reviews on Amazon.
What to know: It’s 20 minutes a round and gets harder as you go, so it’s for couples who like a little challenge.

We’re Not Really Strangers Couples Edition ($20)
Best for: a $20 couples’ party
This is a deck of 150 conversation cards for two from the card game brand most people know from Instagram. It’s easy to steal and easy to use that same night on the drive home. It has 4.6 stars from 2,700 reviews on Amazon.
What to know: Some questions get deep, so it’s better for couples than for a mixed group.
Family White Elephant Gifts (Teens to Grandpa)
A family swap is the hardest crowd, because the gift has to work for a teenager and a grandpa. These are the ones that work for almost anyone.

Sunbeam Heated Microplush Throw ($46.97)
Best for: a $40 or $50 family swap
A heated throw is the gift people fight over at family white elephants, because everyone from your teenager to your grandpa wants one and few people buy one for themselves. Sunbeam’s microplush throw plugs in and warms up in minutes, and it has 4.5 stars from 1,045 reviews at Walmart.
What to know: Bring it to a party where the limit is $40 or more, or it’ll look like you broke the rules.

Hues and Cues ($24.97)
Best for: a mixed-age family game
Hues and Cues is a color-guessing game for 3 to 10 players where one person gives a one- or two-word clue and everyone tries to land on the same shade among 480 squares. A 10 year old and a grandma play on totally equal footing. It has 4.7 stars from more than 10,000 reviews on Amazon.
What to know: It’s ages 8 and up, and it plays best with at least four people.

Wavelength ($34.99)
Best for: teens and adults
In Wavelength, teams try to guess where a clue lands on a dial between two opposites, like hot and cold, and it gets loud fast. It’s the kind of game people ask to play again at the next party. It has 4.5 stars from 342 reviews at Walmart.
What to know: It’s ages 14 and up, so it’s better for a teen and adult swap than a kids’ one.

Poetry for Neanderthals ($19.99)
Best for: a $20 family or friends swap
This is one of the funniest games we own. You give clues using only one-syllable words, and if you slip up, the other team bonks you with an inflatable club. We’ve had ours for years, and it still makes everyone laugh. It has 4.8 stars from almost 10,000 reviews on Amazon.
What to know: Get the regular edition, not the NSFW one, for a family party.

Taco Cat Goat Cheese Pizza ($9.97)
Best for: a $10 swap, or as an add-on
Taco Cat Goat Cheese Pizza is a card game where everyone flips cards and slaps the pile when the card matches the word being said. We own it, and anyone can learn it in about a minute, which is why it usually gets opened and played right there at the party. It has 4.8 stars from more than 55,000 reviews on Amazon.
What to know: At under $10, pair it with a second small game to hit a $20 limit.

Warmies Heatable Plush ($29.99)
Best for: anyone who’s always cold
Warmies are soft stuffed animals filled with flaxseed and lavender that you heat in the microwave, so they’re part cuddly toy and part heating pad. They work for a kid, a teen or a grandma, which makes them one of the safest family-swap gifts.
What to know: Heat it in short bursts and check it before handing it to a little one.

Murdle, Volume 1 ($12.84)
Best for: the puzzle person
Murdle is a book of short murder-mystery logic puzzles, each one solved with a little grid of suspects, weapons and rooms. It’s perfect for the person who does the crossword every morning, and it’s under $15. It has 4.5 stars.
What to know: It’s a book, so it’s a great add-on for a $25 limit.

Apple AirTag (2nd Generation) ($23)
Best for: a $25 family or office swap
An AirTag is a little tracker that goes on keys, a backpack or a suitcase so you can find it with your phone. It was on four different gift guides this year, and it gets fought over because it’s useful for literally anyone with an iPhone. It has 4.5 stars from 1,397 reviews at Walmart.
What to know: It only works with an iPhone, so it’s a dud for anyone with an Android.

Kids’ Gift Exchange Ideas
We host kids’ gift exchanges at our house, sometimes for a whole school class on a Saturday morning. It’s one of the easiest parties to host because the exchange is the main activity: food goes out, the kids run around, then everyone sits in a circle. These are the gifts that got stolen at ours, plus the ones I expect to this year.

Pokémon TCG 30th Celebration Mini Tin ($9.99)
Best for: ages 6 to 12
Pokémon cards got stolen at our kids’ exchange, and this year’s 30th anniversary cards are the ones kids want. A mini tin has booster packs in a little collectible tin, and it’s a perfect $10 gift.
What to know: Buy it at list price from GameStop, Target, Walmart or the Pokémon Center. Resellers are asking $30 and up for the same tin.

NeeDoh Nice Cube ($5.99)
Best for: ages 5 to 12
The NeeDoh Nice Cube is a squishy, dough-filled fidget cube, and it’s the school craze of 2026. I fully expect these to get stolen at our exchange this year. Bundle two at list price for a $10 or $15 limit.
What to know: Never heat it, and buy from a real store. Marketplace sellers are charging $25 for a $6 cube.

Mystery Squishy Dumpling (about $8 to $12)
Best for: ages 6 to 12
These squishy dumplings are the other 2026 squishy craze, and I’d bet on them getting stolen at our exchange this year. Each one comes in a little takeout-style box, so the reveal is half the fun.
What to know: Buy the originals at Five Below in store. Online they’re mostly resellers and knockoffs, and some versions are filled with beads or water, so NeeDoh is the safer squishy for little kids.

Kids’ Digital Camera ($19.88)
Best for: ages 4 to 9
A kids’ digital camera got stolen at one of our exchanges, and I wasn’t surprised. Every kid wants to take pictures of everyone else. This one is sold by Walmart and has 4.2 stars from 688 reviews. Kids’ cameras are a much better gift than an instant camera, because the film for those gets expensive fast.
What to know: For a $40 limit, the VTech KidiZoom ($39.97) is the sturdier upgrade.

National Geographic Science Kit ($14.97 to $29.99)
Best for: ages 8 to 12
An explosions chemistry kit got stolen at our kids’ exchange, and science kits are always the gift the older kids eye. The National Geographic volcano kit is $14.97 with 4.6 stars from 473 reviews, and the Science Magic kit is $29.99 if your limit is higher.
What to know: Most of these need a grown-up for a few of the experiments, so it’s best for 8 and up.

Kids’ Digital Microscope With a Screen ($24.29)
Best for: ages 4 to 10
This is a handheld microscope with a 2-inch color screen, so kids hold it up to a leaf, a coin or their own skin and see it right on the screen with no eyepiece to squint through. It focuses itself, lights itself and saves up to 200 photos. We have one, and it’s so fun. It has 4.2 stars from 2,390 reviews.
What to know: Videos need a microSD card, which isn’t included.

Bath Bombs With a Toy Surprise Inside, 12 Pack ($28.99)
Best for: ages 3 to 8
We gave these to my youngest, who’s four, and she was obsessed (she hates bubble baths, so bath bombs are her thing). There are 12 scented bath bombs, each with a little dog or cat toy inside, plus a tiny cage, tub and swing to play with after bath time. Twelve surprises in one box is a lot of unwrapping for one kid. They have 4.6 stars from 417 reviews.
What to know: Some of the accessories are sent at random, so it’s not always the exact set in the photo.

3D Nail Art Pens, 12 Colors ($9.99)
Best for: ages 6 to 12
Nail art got stolen at our kids’ exchange last year. These are nail polish pens with a fine 0.7 mm tip, so kids can draw dots, lines and tiny hearts without a brush, and they dry quickly. They have 4.4 stars from 373 reviews.
What to know: At $9.99, add a bottle of clear top coat or a sheet of nail stickers to hit a $15 to $20 limit.

Kanoodle ($9.99)
Best for: ages 7 and up
Kanoodle is a pocket-size puzzle game with more than 200 challenges, and kids love racing each other on the same level. It has 4.6 stars from 1,734 reviews and fits a $10 limit.
What to know: The little pieces are easy to lose, so it’s not for a toddler’s pile.

LEGO Speed Champions Toyota Supra ($23.99)
Best for: ages 10 and up
LEGO is the brand kids get most excited about at an exchange, and a Speed Champions car is a quick build they can finish before the party ends. This one is the Toyota Supra from The Fast and the Furious, with a driver minifigure, and it has 4.7 stars from 522 reviews at Walmart.
What to know: It’s ages 10 and up, so put it in the big-kid pile.

Crazy Aaron’s Thinking Putty ($9.98)
Best for: ages 6 and up
Thinking Putty is the quiet fidget teachers allow in class, and a tin of it comes in colors that shimmer or change color in your hands. It’s a perfect $10 gift.
What to know: Skip the magnetic versions for kids’ parties.

StickiKubes, 125 Pack ($19.99)
Best for: ages 6 and up
StickiKubes are tiny squishy cubes that stick to each other and to almost anything, so kids build towers and creatures with them. They’re part building toy and part fidget, and 125 is plenty to share.
What to know: The cubes are tiny, so keep them away from toddlers.

Rubik’s Cube ($9.49)
Best for: ages 8 and up
Cube solving is a real school flex again, and a Rubik’s Cube is a classic $10 gift for the big kids. Get the official one, since cheap cubes stick and pop apart.
What to know: Add a printed beginner’s guide if the kid hasn’t solved one before.
Office White Elephant Gift Ideas
For an office swap, the gift needs to be useful and impossible to be offended by. The AirTag, Murdle, Poetry for Neanderthals and the crochet animals all work here too.

Owala FreeSip Water Bottle, 24 oz ($24)
Best for: a $25 office swap
The Owala FreeSip is the insulated bottle that replaced the Stanley, with a built-in straw and a spout so you can sip or swig. It’s the one gift almost everyone at work would actually use.
What to know: Pick a neutral color for an office swap.

Snarky Affirmations Desk Calendar ($15)
Best for: a $15 office swap
This is a tear-away desk calendar with a snarky affirmation for every day, the office-safe kind of funny. It has 4.6 stars from 10 reviews at Uncommon Goods.
What to know: It’s a tear-away, so it sits on a desk all year.
Funny White Elephant Gifts People Still Want
For a gag gift exchange, the best gifts are the funny ones someone actually takes home and uses. These get the laugh and don’t end up in the trash.

Squatty Potty ($24.99)
Best for: a gag exchange with grown-ups
The Squatty Potty is a toilet stool that gets the biggest laugh when it’s unwrapped and then quietly goes home and gets used. It’s the gag gift that keeps coming up every year.
What to know: Know your crowd: it’s perfect for friends and a little much for a work party.

Butter Socks ($14)
Best for: a $15 gag swap
These are yellow cotton socks printed to look like a stick of butter, measurement markers and all. They’re silly, they’re soft, and they’ve shown up on three gift guides this year. They have 5 stars from 20 reviews.
What to know: They come in two sizes, so pick the large for a mixed group.

Bob Ross Chia Pet ($19.97)
Best for: a $20 gag exchange
It’s a Chia Pet, but it’s Bob Ross, and his famous hair grows in green. It gets a laugh at every party and it actually grows, so someone always wants to take it home.
What to know: The seeds come in the box, so it’s ready to grow.

Melting Snowball Mystery Cash Bath Bomb ($12)
Best for: a $10 to $15 swap
This snowball bath bomb fizzes away in the tub to reveal a random amount of real money: $1, $5, $10 or $20. It’s my hidden gift card idea in gag form, and the mystery makes it fun to steal.
What to know: The amount is random, so treat it as a fun gamble.

Poorly Explained Movies ($18)
Best for: teens and adults
It’s a party game where you guess the movie from a hilariously bad description, with 300 cards for 2 to 8 players. It’s the kind of game that gets played the minute someone wins it. It has 5 stars from 8 reviews.
What to know: It’s ages 12 and up.

Mystic Pickle ($19.99)
Best for: a $20 gag exchange
The Mystic Pickle is a talking pickle that answers any yes-or-no question with one of 100 sassy responses. Pass it around the circle and everyone asks it something. It has 4.5 stars from 708 reviews.
What to know: Reviewers say the speaker is on the quiet side, so it’s funnier in a small room.

Emotional Support Crochet Animals, Set of 6 ($25.99)
Best for: a $25 gag or office swap
These are six tiny crocheted animals, including a pickle, a turtle, a sloth and a chicken, each with its own little pep-talk card. We ordered these and use them. It’s a gag gift people actually keep on their desks, and with six of them, the winner can hand a few out. They have 4.8 stars from 96 reviews.
What to know: The animals in the set vary a little, so you may not get the exact six in the photo.
White Elephant Rules (and the Versions I Like)
White elephant is a gift exchange game where everyone brings one wrapped gift, draws a number, and either opens a new gift or steals one that’s already been opened. Here are the basic rules, and the versions I like.
The basic white elephant rules
- Set a price limit and say it as a number. “$25” works better than “around $20 or $30.”
- Everyone puts a wrapped gift in the pile and draws a number.
- Player 1 opens a gift. Each player after that opens a new gift or steals an opened one.
- If your gift is stolen, you open a new one or steal from someone else (but not the gift that was just taken from you).
- A gift can be stolen three times, then it’s frozen with its third owner.
- When everyone has a gift, player 1 gets one last chance to swap.
The versions I like
- Pick your limit for the crowd. My most recent birthday party was $25, I’ve done $40 in past years, and the favorite things party I go to every December is $50. Our couples’ parties were usually $50.
- The three-gift swap. Everyone brings three things worth $10 each and goes home with three different ones. It’s great for a favorite things party, since you get to share more of your favorites.
- Give it a theme. A date night edition, a cozy edition, or a “something you’d use every day” edition makes shopping easier for everyone.
Rules for a kids’ gift exchange
- Say the limit as a number to the parents, not just “something small.”
- Make two piles by age (about 5 to 7 and 8 to 12) so a 5 year old doesn’t open a 12 year old’s gift.
- For little kids, skip stealing and play pass-left, pass-right while you read a story, so nobody cries.
- Keep two or three spare wrapped gifts for the kid who forgot, or the one who ends up with something that doesn’t fit.
White Elephant Gifts That Flop
A few gifts get passed over every year, no matter the party.
- Kitchen gadgets at a mom party. Moms will use them, but they get far more excited about perfume for themselves.
- Generic bath and lotion sets. Most women already have a drawer full.
- Candles in a scent you guessed. A great pine candle in December works, a random scent usually doesn’t.
- Plain socks on their own. They were the most common office-swap disappointment in the research I read.
- Adult gag gifts at a family swap. Save those for friends.
- Gifts way under the limit. Over the limit on purpose is fine; under it makes the person who opens it feel shortchanged.
What I Brought (and Took Home) This Year
For my own birthday exchange this year, I brought an IPSY bag (of course), and I went home with dry shampoo from Living Proof, which is the very best dry shampoo. It’s exactly the kind of gift that wins at these parties: something everyone uses, in the version most people don’t buy for themselves.

If you’re still stuck, start with the party. For a girls’ night, bring something she’s seen everywhere and hasn’t bought, like Dime perfume or the rhode Pocket Pair. For a family swap, it’s hard to beat the heated throw or Poetry for Neanderthals. For more ideas, see my gifts for women who have everything, gifts for mom and, for the kids on your list, my gifts for 8 year old girls and 8 year old boys guides.
And whatever you bring, wrap it well. A great gift in a great box gets stolen twice as fast.
White Elephant Gift Ideas: FAQ
A good white elephant gift is something everyone in the room would want but hasn’t bought for themselves, like Dime perfume, a Sunbeam heated throw or Poetry for Neanderthals. Match it to the kind of party first, since a gag exchange and a girls’ night want very different gifts.
At the parties I’ve hosted and gone to, the most-stolen gifts are viral perfume like Dime, a nail salon gift card and a restaurant gift card with a reservation. At kids’ exchanges, Pokémon cards, a kids’ camera and a science kit got stolen the most.
Most white elephants set a limit between $20 and $50, and $25 is the most common. Stick close to the number, or go a little over on purpose with something like the Quince Balsam Fir candle ($50) or the heated throw ($46.97).
Everyone brings one wrapped gift and draws a number. Each player opens a new gift or steals an opened one, and a gift can be stolen three times before it’s frozen. At the end, player 1 gets one last chance to swap.
It depends on the party. At a gag exchange, bring something funny people still use, like the Squatty Potty or the Mystic Pickle. At a girls’ night, family or office swap, bring something useful, like the Owala FreeSip or the Laneige Midnight Minis.
Great $25 white elephant gifts are the Laneige Midnight Minis ($23), the AirTag ($23), Hues and Cues ($24.97) and, if you can stretch a little, five IPSY products in an IPSY bag (about $30, worth over $120).
For a kids’ exchange, the Pokémon 30th Celebration Mini Tin ($9.99), a NeeDoh Nice Cube, the kids’ digital microscope ($24.29) and the Toylink bath bombs with toys inside ($28.99) are all big hits. Make separate piles by age so the little kids get little-kid gifts.
