|

Is Color Analysis Worth It? My Professional Color Analysis Review (Cardigan Empire)

Today we’re talking all about color analysis, my experience, and whether it’s worth it. This post is not sponsored (but, yes, I love Reachel) and I don’t get any affiliate payout if you book with her.

Elisabeth McKnight in a muted sage blazer, cream top and flare jeans

Short answer: yes, it was SO worth it for me, and two years later I still use it. I had a Premium Color Analysis with Reachel Bagley of Cardigan Empire, and I’ve pulled out the packet she made me more times than I can count.

I’ve talked to a lot of friends who have had their colors done, and from what I’ve heard, a lot of them came away with a season name and a palette and not much else. Mine went a lot further. My biggest takeaway was simple: I look best in cool, muted colors, and knowing exactly which ones to focus on has saved me from a lot of impulse purchases. But Reachel also taught me how to use my features to wear the colors that aren’t my best and what times it matters most to pick my best colors.

So the real question is this: does a color analysis give you enough practical guidance to change how you shop? Here’s what mine included, what it cost, and what I’d do differently.

Professional color analysis results printed and laid on a table

What Is Color Analysis?

Color analysis is the process of finding the colors that harmonize with your natural coloring: your skin, eyes and hair. Many analysts, including Reachel, use a twelve-season system. Each season is defined by three qualities:

  • Hue: warm, cool or neutral coloring
  • Value: how light or deep your coloring is, and how much contrast there is between your features
  • Chroma: clear, saturated colors vs soft, muted ones

An analyst compares colors against your face (usually with fabric drapes or swatches), watches how your skin, eyes and the shadows on your face respond, and places you in the season that fits. The point is to show you which version of each color makes you look rested + alive and which one makes you look tired + dull.

My Experience With Reachel Bagley of Cardigan Empire

I met Reachel at a blogging conference and had wanted to do a color analysis with her for a long time. Finally, during our family’s 8 month stint living in Utah, we made it happen. We were together for about an hour and it has been, hands down, the best hour for helping me get dressed ever since.

Color analyst Reachel Bagley of Cardigan Empire draping Elisabeth McKnight in color swatches during her color analysis

Reachel is a Utah-based stylist who runs Cardigan Empire. She’s also a college fashion professor and Anthropologie’s top personal stylist, and she’s a style guest on KSL TV in Salt Lake City, including a Studio 5 segment on finding your color season. She’s an expert and it comes through in her analysis.

Elisabeth McKnight with color analyst Reachel Bagley of Cardigan Empire

Afterward, she sent my follow-up: a full digital packet with my results. That packet is what I still use.

What’s Included in a Premium Color Analysis

Here’s what was in mine, page by page. (Reachel’s packages may have changed since I went in, so check her site for the current details.)

Color theory for my face. One page each on hue, value and chroma, explaining exactly where I land and why. Mine came out neutral leaning cool, medium-low contrast, and soft.

My primary season and two secondary seasons. I’m a soft summer first, cool summer second and soft autumn third. She labels them best, better and good. Each season gets its own palette of sixteen colors plus a row of worst colors, all shown around a photo of my face.

Primary and secondary color seasons compared on the same face

Draped comparisons. My face circled in my best colors next to my worst colors, and next to close calls from my sister seasons. These have been the most helpful pages and I reference them when making big shopping decisions.

Color combinations and neutrals. Monochromatic, complementary, analogous and triad pairings from my palette, plus pattern guidance and my best neutrals.

Cosmetics. Foundation tones, lip and cheek shades, eyeshadow colors and liner colors, with specific product examples for each.

Hair color. My current color, five soft summer alternatives, and AI mockups of my own face with a level 8 beige blonde, a level 9 ash blonde and a level 7 smoky brown. This has been helpful when deciding whether or not I want to change my hair and what to ask for at the salon.

Face shape and glasses. My face shape (oval), and the frame shapes, styles and colors that suit it.

Jewelry metals. Which metals flatter my skin.

A twelve-season visual comparison. My face dropped into all twelve season wheels, each labeled with why it doesn’t work (too light, too warm, too bright and so on).

I’m going deep on my actual results, including every color in all three palettes, in an upcoming post on my soft summer color palette.

Why My Color Analysis Was Better Than Most

Everyone expects to come out of a color analysis knowing their best colors and, yes, this was very helpful. What set Reachel’s analysis apart is that she went beyond my best colors and taught me how to use my features to wear everything else.

She taught me how to wear colors outside my palette. I have low contrast between my skin, eyes and hair, so a high contrast color like black washes me out. Instead of telling me to never wear black, she taught me to add the contrast my face doesn’t have, with more mascara and done brows. If I’m committed to a little black dress for an event, I just make sure I’m adding contrast back in. I also know that a little bit of self tanner goes a long way when wearing black. The same goes for jewel tones and bright colors.

She taught me to use distance from my face. A color that isn’t my best can still work further from my face. A jewel tone in a holiday pant is a much better plan than a jewel tone sweater.

She told me when it matters most. Color matters most for things I wear without makeup, like gym clothes and swimsuits, and it matters less when I’ve got makeup on. She also told me I can wear a wider range of colors in the summer when I have a bit of a tan.

She covered neutrals too. I learned that pure white washes me out, while ivory, a grayish white or an antique cream is much more flattering. That one note changed how I buy basics. A cream layering tee is much better on me than a stark white layering tee and this advice has talked me out of so many crisp white pieces I gravitate toward on the hanger but don’t do me any favors.

She covered metals. My complexion leans cool with subtle warmth, so muted silver and rose gold are my best, with white gold and soft yellow gold also working. I can wear gold, but I look a little better in silver. (I still own way more gold, so I wear it plenty.)

And her color wheel includes every color. If you look at it, every color is on there, just not every shade of every color. That reframed the whole thing for me. A good color analysis is really a guide to wearing each color well and less about what not to wear.

Best colors vs worst colors draped on the same face

How Much Does Color Analysis Cost?

Color analysis prices are all over the place. Just google how much someone costs in your area to get an estimate. Cardigan Empire’s current pricing as of November 2026:

  • Essential Color Analysis: $75. Your seasonal color category, best colors, colors to avoid, and ideas for pairing and wearing your season.
  • Premium Color Analysis (what I had): $150. Everything in Essential plus premium services like makeup recommendations, hair color recommendations and face shape identification with a glasses guide.
  • Ultimate Fashion Profile: $250. Everything in Premium plus body type identification, signature style identification, closet cleaning tips, where-to-shop recommendations and capsule wardrobe strategies.

Her site also lists live services in the Salt Lake area, including color analysis parties starting at $250 and in-person shopping and closet sessions.

For comparison, when I looked into in-person color analysis here in Southern California, the quotes I remember were around $400. Checking current prices, independent studios in Los Angeles run about $245 to $300 for an in-person session, and House of Colour consultants across the US charge roughly $255 to $475. Reachel’s packages were way more affordable than some of the in-person options I was looking at here.

In-Person vs Online Color Analysis

I had mine in person, and seeing the swatches on my face in real time was so fun. But I wouldn’t let that stop you from booking a virtual one. Reachel’s virtual packages are done from photos and a digital survey, and the packet you get back is the same kind of personalized document I’ve been using for two years.

10/10 I’d trust Reachel and her expertise for a virtual appointment.

Elisabeth McKnight holding a color swatch next to color analyst Reachel Bagley

What Changed After My Color Analysis

My shopping. I focus on cool, muted colors now. If something catches my eye in a color that isn’t on my list, I know before I try it on that it won’t be my best, and that alone has kept a lot of impulse purchases out of my cart. Right now it’s talking me out of all the fun, trendy chartreuse, and it has talked me out of a few pure white pieces too, including a great white Lululemon jacket this summer.

My hair. Every fall, I want warm honey blonde highlights and warm lowlights. My packet talked me out of it. Reachel’s rule is to stay within two shades of my natural color and look for ash, soft or neutral tones, and to avoid golden and copper. Seeing the AI mockups of my own face made it hard to argue with.

Hair color recommendations with AI mockups from a color analysis

My makeup. I didn’t go out and buy the exact products in my packet. I buy whatever I was going to buy anyway, in the shades she recommended: neutral pinks, rose and mauve for lips and cheeks, and matte or satin shadows in mauve, dusty grape, slate blue and jade.

My basics. I buy my Mott & Bow tees in ivory or soft colors like Honeydew instead of stark white, and creamy Quince sweaters instead of pure white ones. For reds, I go with more of a berry red instead of an orangey red.

My investment pieces. If something is trendy and I’ll only wear it for a year, I care more about loving it than about the color. But the long-term pieces I’m trying to build my wardrobe around always come from my palette. I coveted the Vince Boiled Cashmere Funnel Neck sweater for five years before buying it last year in a light heathered gray, and I loved it so much I bought it again this season in a muted, mauvey purple. Both are squarely in my colors and pieces I’ll love and wear for years.

How I shop trends. Brown is huge right now, and warm browns are really bad on me, but cool browns work. Knowing that tells me exactly which version of the trend to buy.

My gym clothes and swimsuits. These are where I stick closest to my palette, because there’s no makeup to balance a bad color. My Left on Friday suits in Desert Plum and Jam and the Alo sets my husband gave me for Christmas (ivory and a dusty green) all landed right in my colors. My go-to gym jacket is this one from Quince (it’s a Lululemon dupe I bought after my Lululemon one BROKE in the wash) in my perfect blue.

What I’d Do Differently

Looking at her packages now, I wish I’d booked a styling session too. The Ultimate Fashion Profile adds body type identification, and knowing my body type alongside my colors would have been really useful. If you’re deciding between Premium and Ultimate, I’d look hard at Ultimate.

What I Love / What to Know

What I love:

  • Knowing exactly which colors to focus on, which has cut down my impulse purchases
  • Guidance on how to wear colors outside my palette, so it never feels limiting
  • Three seasons (best, better, good) instead of one, which gives a much bigger shopping list
  • Practical extras: neutrals, metals, makeup shades, hair tones and glasses
  • AI hair color mockups on my own photo
  • A packet I’ve used for two years
  • Affordable compared with the in-person options I looked at in Southern California

What to know:

  • In-person appointments are mainly in the Salt Lake area (her site mentions travel for an added fee)
  • Body type analysis is only in the higher Ultimate tier
  • The cosmetics page names specific products, but you don’t need to buy them; shopping in your shades works fine

Is Color Analysis Worth It?

For me, yes. The biggest payoff is that I know which colors to focus on (cool, muted shades like misty teal, dusty grape and deep rose). That keeps me away from impulse purchases in colors that were never going to be my best, and it stopped me from a hair color I would have regretted. It also has helped a lot when choosing between colors for a piece I love (if a dress comes in a handful of colors, for example).

If you want to see what a real analysis looks like, my full soft summer color palette results are coming in their own post soon. And if you book with Reachel, I’d love to hear what season you are!

Color Analysis FAQ

What is color analysis?

Color analysis is a way to find the colors that harmonize with your natural skin, eye and hair coloring. Many analysts use a twelve-season system based on warm vs cool, light vs deep, and clear vs soft.

How much does a color analysis cost?

Cardigan Empire’s virtual packages currently range from $75 to $250 (as of November 2026). In-person sessions cost more: independent Los Angeles studios run about $245 to $300, and House of Colour consultants charge roughly $255 to $475.

Is online color analysis accurate?

It depends on the analyst and the photos you send. I had mine in person, but Reachel’s virtual packages produce the same kind of personalized packet, and a good analyst will give you secondary seasons too, which builds in some flexibility.

How long does a color analysis take?

My in-person appointment with Reachel took about an hour, and my full packet came afterward.

What’s included in a professional color analysis?

At minimum, your season and best and worst colors. My Premium Color Analysis also included two secondary seasons, color combinations, neutrals, makeup shades, hair color recommendations with AI mockups, jewelry metals and a glasses guide.

Is color analysis real or just a trend?

It’s been around for decades and got a second life on social media. Even if you’re skeptical of the seasons themselves, seeing your face next to your best and worst colors makes the difference hard to ignore.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *