An Honest Quince Review (After Owning 20+ Pieces): What’s Worth It In 2026
Today we’re talking all about my favorite pieces from Quince. I’m sharing sizing and quality details on all the pieces I’ve ordered over the last four years—and which ones are actually worth buying. This honest Quince review is not sponsored but may contain affiliate links.
I first tried Quince four years ago when I ordered cashmere sweaters as gifts for family members. After stealing my husband’s sweater multiple times (I think I wear it more than he does), it was time to get my own.
Quince is known for classic styles made from high-end fabrics (think silk and cashmere) at moderate prices. They list the traditional retail price next to their lower price, which gives serious sale dopamine even when you’re paying full price.
But the real question is this: how do Quince pieces actually hold up over time? Is Quince legit? Are these timeless staples—or is this fast fashion in disguise?
In this post, I’ll review everything I’ve ordered from Quince over the last four years and share what I’d buy again, what I’d skip, and what to know before you order.
Best Quince Pieces for Women
⭐ Favorite Overall: Cotton Fisherman Sweater ($40)
This is an exceptional sweater for the price.
Comparable to Madewell or Jenni Kayne cotton fisherman sweaters—but under $50. I like this one BETTER than my Jenni Kayne cotton fisherman sweater (Jenni Kayne does a better job at cashmere than Quince but not cotton fisherman).
This is the best 100% cotton sweater under $50. (I will die on this hill.)
I sized up to a small for an oversized, cozy fit. It runs true to size.
👉 If you buy one thing from Quince, make it this. Also, it is worth noting that they don’t always restock colors. I waited too long on this sweater in a light blue and then it sold out they never brought it back. I’m still kicking myself a year later.
Cashmere Boyfriend Cardigan
This is the cardigan that started the love affair.
It’s cool, easy, and incredibly soft with a slouchy, oversized fit. I ordered my regular size (XS) and it’s perfect. If I could trade all my other sweaters for this in every color, I would.
Quality note: I’ve owned this sweater for a few years and wore it very regularly. After a couple of months, it began to pill. I’ve washed it only once or twice. I use a cashmere comb to help with the pilling. I loved it so much I invested in the actual Jenni Kayne Cashmere Cocoon … and it turns out, that one ALSO pills after a few months
👉 If $500 for a sweater doesn’t phase you, the Jenni Kayne one is a little thicker and softer BUT I still love this $140 version and would buy again.
Silk Maxi Skirt
This skirt is stunning and paired with the cashmere tee in the same color, it made up my most complimented outfit of 2025. Its a lightweight silk that drapes beautifully. It has an elastic waistband. 10/10 would recommend and I’m eying it in champagne for spring/summer.
Mongolian Cashmere Tee
This has quietly become one of my most-worn Quince pieces—and one I’ve repurchased in multiple colors, which tells you everything.
The cashmere tee instantly elevates even the most basic outfit. It gives you texture and polish without the warmth of a full sweater, making it perfect for transitional weather (hello California winter) and cool summer days.
Fit & sizing: I own this in multiple sizes and colors. It runs true to size for a classic fit. I like a slightly relaxed look and tend to size up.
Fabric note: The lighter colors (especially ivory/cream) are slightly sheer. I don’t mind this layered or with the right bra, but it’s worth knowing before you order.
Quality: There is some pilling after the 5th or 6th wear (like all the cashmere) but nothing a little cashmere comb can’t fix. This feels like a true staple and a repeat-buy piece for me.
👉 Highly recommend. One of Quince’s best basics.
Leather Belts
If the belt you want is in your size and in stock, order it. It is hard to get the brown and black in stock and so I finally just ordered the white to see if these lived up to the hype. Full leather belt at under $50?
These are minimalist and chic. I love that they come in the same colors as a lot of Quince’s leather shoes so you can achieve that chic fashion secret of matching your belt to your shoes.
I bought the Sophia European Skinny Leather Belt in Bone and Mushroom. Perfection.
Sunglasses
I’m genuinely obsessed with Quince sunglasses—and I don’t say that lightly.
I own multiple pairs, including the Brixton and Tucson polarized acetate styles, and they absolutely hold their own against much more expensive brands. They feel substantial without being heavy, and the lenses are genuinely good quality.
Style notes: Both styles feel modern but not trendy, which means they won’t look dated next season. They’re easy to wear daily and don’t feel precious.
Value: For $50 polarized sunglasses, these are a standout. I got them on a sale for 2 for $80. They come with a dust bag, a case, and in a box. The packaging is elevated and these would make a great gift.
👉 One of my favorite accessories from Quince and an easy yes.
Women’s $50 Cashmere V-Neck
I’m wearing a small here. These sweaters are fitted, so I recommend sizing up:
- Size up one for a similar fit to mine
- Size up two for an oversized look
I love tossing this over my shoulders during our fake California fall.
Quality note: After 4+ wears, I noticed pilling starting. Cashmere is high-maintenance.
Washable Silk Tee
One of my favorite Quince purchases.
This tee elevates any outfit and is incredibly versatile—and yes, it’s actually washable. I’ve worn and washed it for over a year and a half, and it has held up beautifully.
Sizing note:
- Order your regular size for a close fit
- Size up one for a looser fit (I wish I had)
Minor con: my hair sometimes snags on the back button clasp.
Basic Cotton Modal Tee ($15)
A solid basic, especially for layering.
It’s thin, comfortable, and slightly sheer. I love it under sweaters in winter, but the neckline did stretch out over time. If I were buying another tee, I would order this boxy 100% cotton one instead.
Sizing: This tee is fitted. I’m wearing a small but will size up to a medium next time.
Best Quince Shoes & Bags
Italian Leather Quilted Crossbody Bag
A great everyday bag that gives YSL vibes without the logo or price.
The taupe color is beautiful, and while the leather is thinner and softer than my Mansur Gavriel bag, it feels comparable to something you’d pay ~$200+ for.
I haven’t carried it extensively yet, so I’ll update this section with long-term wear notes.
Italian Leather Horsebit Loafer Mule
These are beautiful right out of the box and very clear Gucci horsebit–inspired dupes—without the logo or the four-figure price tag.
I’ve only just unboxed them, but my first impression is extremely positive. The leather feels soft and supple, the hardware looks polished (not cheap), and they were comfortable immediately with no obvious break-in pain. That alone is a win for a structured leather mule.
Fit & comfort: They feel true to size for me, with enough structure to feel secure but not stiff. Easy to slip on, easy to walk in—at least initially.
Style notes: These are the kind of shoe that instantly elevates a basic outfit. Jeans and a tee, a simple dress, even tailored pants—they give that polished, European look with very little effort.
Longevity: This is the one question mark. I’ll be curious to see how the leather and sole hold up with regular wear, and I’ll update this section once I’ve worn them more.
👉 Gorgeous, comfy out of the box, and a very convincing designer-style dupe so far.
Best Quince Pieces for Men
Men’s Mongolian Cashmere Crewneck
Originally purchased as a Christmas gift for my husband—and now officially mine.
This sweater has more weight than the women’s $50 cashmere (possibly because it’s a men’s medium). It gives sweatshirt-level comfort with cashmere polish. Slouchy, cozy, and endlessly wearable.
10/10. This also makes an excellent gift that feels more expensive than it is.
I also bought my husband the cashmere henley and the cashmere crewneck sweatshirt for Christmas. We’ll see how they hold out but so far they seem like a perfect way to upgrade basics.
What I Don’t Recommend for Men
Men’s 24/7 Smart Chinos
I ordered two pairs for my husband, and within a month of regular wear, they were visibly worn.
👉 These are a skip.
Best Quince Sleepwear & Loungewear (Women)
100% European Linen Pajama Set
These pajamas are beautifully made, breathable, and high quality—but I’ll be honest: I just can’t get into linen pajamas.
There’s nothing wrong with them construction-wise. The fabric is substantial and well done, but for sleep, I personally prefer something softer and drapier. Linen makes sense for warm-weather clothing; for pajamas, it just isn’t my thing. I wish I had just ordered a linen set from Quince because I’ve heard GREAT things about their linen. I just need to order it in a different piece.
👉 Objectively well made, but not a personal repurchase for me.
Best Quince Pieces for Kids
Kids Fisherman Cashmere Sweater
This is one of the sweetest, most elevated kids’ pieces for holidays or family photos.
It’s soft, medium-weight, and cozy—and has been handed down from two siblings while still looking great.
If I repurchased: I’d choose the oatmeal color for better kid-friendliness.
Baby Cashmere Jogger Set
A gorgeous, cozy baby set that’s perfect for photos and gifting.
Our baby has only worn it a handful of times (crawling destroys knees), so I recommend this for pre-crawling or post-crawling stages.
This makes a fantastic baby gift—especially for parents who already have everything.
What I Don’t Recommend for Kids
100% Organic Cotton Bikini Underwear (7‑Pack)
I wanted to love these because they’re 100% cotton (and please—stop buying kids polyester underwear). Unfortunately, the elastic just wasn’t great.
While I appreciate the breathable cotton fabric, the waistband didn’t hold up the way I’d expect for everyday kid wear.
A few more things on my Quince wish list:
(Items I’m considering next—this section will be updated as I try more pieces.)
- Washable Silk Tee in another color: I love my washable black silk tee but wish I would have sized up. I’m eying the blue and the red.
- Cashmere belted jacket (a cool $500 but so gorgeous)
- Leather pouch crossbody clutch: This gives strong designer vibes (I’ve been eying the Mansur Gavriel cloud clutch for a minute and this one looks very similar for a fraction of the price)
- Oversized Striped Linen Shirt: I have heard great things about Quince’s linen line. I love a breezy button-down for some added sun coverage on all our beach + pool days. I’m just trying to figure out which colorway to order a linen shirt and pants or shorts for my go-to summer set.
- Chunky Cardigan: My sister bought this sweater in brown last fall and it is SO cute. It works with jeans as well as dress pants and over dresses.
- Quince Bedding (especially sheets + duvet covers — curious about fabric feel, durability, and how it compares to other mid-range bedding brands)
- Woven Leather Bag (very Bottega Veneta–inspired without the price tag; interested in leather quality, weight, and how it holds its shape)
- Cashmere Fisherman Crew: Our favorite cotton sweater in cashmere. My sister got this for her birthday and says its her new obsession.
Conclusion: Will I order from Quince again?
Absolutely.
Quince Clothing FAQ:
Yes, I find their clothing runs true to size. Many of their pieces are fitted so you might want to consider sizing up for a looser fit.
For example, I find the cotton modal tee shirt from Quince runs 1-2 sizes small in comparison to drapey, looser fitting tees from other brands. If you want a fitted tee, order your regular size. If you want a slightly oversized fit, which has become the norm for a lot of tee shirts, go 1-2 sizes up.
Most of the clothing sold by Quince is made from sustainable materials.
Quince focuses on timeless and classic styles. They’ll lean into trends that will stick around in your closet. So this season you’ll see a lot more of the slip skirt (a big trend this season but something you can always wear). You won’t find anything with peplum, tweed, or polka dots (more trends that won’t age as well as the slip skirt).
I would categorize Quince as a medium-fashion. It isn’t a Shein but it isn’t setting the bar for quality pieces that are going to last you 10 years.
The majority of clothing sold by Quince is made using sustainable materials and produced by manufacturers dedicated to providing a high-quality work environment.
Quince has a generous 365 day return policy. There are a few exceptions and most things must be in unworn or unwashed condition.
